Well, like I have repeatedly said, you haven't actually commented on why my 3 reasons for him being mentally is is wrong.
What are you deliberately leaving out?
Why aren't you addressing the core issue besides the general statement about addressing claims of a mentally ill man?
Well I've commented on all of these but let me put them in one place for you.
He doesn't know the topic - clue #1
I simply believe this is false. I don't think I have received a counter to this. Such as, what information is he unaware of, what information of his is false, that sort of thing.
His stories are internally consistent in a weird way the way mentally ill people construct them - clue #2
I previously slapped this under "mannerisms".. If you're classifying someone as mentally insane by having consistent logic then I'm not exactly sure what to tell you. I guess you could elaborate on what you mean by "how mentally ill people" construct logic but I doubt that discussion will bear any fruit.
HIs body language doesn't match his word - clue #3
I also slapped this under mannerisms, and as I said before I've never actually watched him move while talking before. And as I have also said before, I don't really care about his mannerisms, I care about information presented, which was your first point.
Okay, well now we are playing fair game. Why didn't you do this earlier?
I accept your perspective. That's fine.
(post is archived)