Crensch you didn't create the sub. It was created by 1 year ago.
So it wouldn't be taking over the sub.
I would welcome anyone to check the sublog and look at your behavior and judge for themselves.
You have banned more people than any other sub on poal by far.
We the admins have done nothing but be accommodating to you. We haven't reversed a single ban you've made. We haven't taken the sub from you.
The only thing we haven't done is give you Owner status and that is because of your behavior banning people who haven't participated. Which you have now done multiple times.
I have spoken with you politely multiple times. I am trying to manage this situation in a respectful and professional way. However abusive mod behavior is against the Terms of Service. I wrote that in there specifically to handle situations where a mod wants me to bend a knee when they want to censor people.
I can't do that and you know I can't. You are being manipulative and underhanded and I don't appreciate it.
We expect if you want to remain here you will apologize for this nonsense and we can behave like adults. If not that is entirely up to you but we will not be coerced into letting someone censor people.
The only thing we haven't done is give you Owner status and that is because of your behavior banning people who haven't participated. Which you have now done multiple times.
This is where you lie.
I originally did that upon coming here when Voat shut down. You THEN informed me it was wrong... AFTER it became a problem for you, not when you first noticed it.
I agreed to NOT do that again.
You set the ground rules that if I didn't ban anyone for 10 days AT ALL, and then ONLY banned users that INTERACTED WITH (participated in) my sub.
I did EXACTLY that.
I can prove it.
Check the subs I've blocked. I can't even SEE other subs now. Why would I care what they did?
I have spoken with you politely multiple times. I am trying to manage this situation in a respectful and professional way. However abusive mod behavior is against the Terms of Service. I wrote that in there specifically to handle situations where a mod wants me to bend a knee when they want to censor people.
Show me where what I've done is abusive.
I can't do that and you know I can't. You are being manipulative and underhanded and I don't appreciate it.
I reached out to you and asked for specific guidelines. I FOLLOWED EVERY SINGLE ONE.
Show me a SINGLE user that DID NOT INTERACT WITH MY SUB since you stopped me from banning for 10 days.
JUST ONE.
We expect if you want to remain here you will apologize for this nonsense and we can behave like adults. If not that is entirely up to you but we will not be coerced into letting someone censor people.
You can apologize for leaving the threat open, not being clear with what I needed to do to acquire the sub, then when we finally (I thought) clarified, WHICH YOU CLARIFIED HERE I WAS RIGHT, and I DID EXACTLY THAT, you wrote to me and said you wouldn't give me the sub because of my banlist.
TL;DR:
I banned people.
You told me not to ban users that had not interacted with my sub.
I blocked EVERY sub that comes up in /new so I wouldn't even notice anyone outside of my sub.
I banned NOBODY that had not COMMENTED in my sub, which you just confirmed above IS THE EXACT stipulation.
My banlist growing has fuck-all to do with anything beyond the fact that THEY PARTICIPATED IN MY SUB and they don't belong.
You told me anyway that somehow what I have done is wrong, and I would not get the sub. That my banlist was NOT OKAY despite the fact that they ALL PARTICIPATED in my sub.
You told me that was a problem.
You ALSO told me that ALTS were not a thing here.
You lied. They pop up constantly.
I did my job. I held up my end of every single agreement we've had.
You must be the other guy.
Please re check the sub log. I think you might have forgotten some things that you did.
Crensch you can call me a liar, but the logs are public. Anyone can see them.
I'm not going to go through the logs and make a list of every single user and where they interacted with you and why you banned them. I recommend you check the logs.
I will not hand over Owner status of a sub to someone who can't handle dissenting opinions. If you had created the sub, which you are more than welcome to make one and you have the ability to do that. It wouldn't be any of my business but you are asking me to make an admin choice to hand a previously created sub owned by an undeleted user to you because you want it and if I don't do it you are going to make a huge deal about it and threaten me in PMs about making it a public debate.
That type of behavior shows me you are not someone I want to hand Ownership status of anything to.
I'm a pretty reasonable guy but I do not respond well to threats.
You wanted it public so here it is all out in the open.
You ban at the first sign of dissent, and if you had created it, it wouldn't be my business. However when you asked me to hand you ownership you made it my business. You are already a mod and I haven't done anything to change that.
I am sincerely sorry I can't do what you want but I have to follow my best judgement and the way you have behaved sets off some pretty loud alarm bells for me, specifically threats.
Please re check the sub log. I think you might have forgotten some things that you did.
Crensch you can call me a liar, but the logs are public. Anyone can see them.
I forgot nothing. I know exactly what I did and did not do.
I'm not going to go through the logs and make a list of every single user and where they interacted with you and why you banned them. I recommend you check the logs.
EVERY SINGLE USER POSTED A COMMENT IN MY THIS SUB.
I will not hand over Owner status of a sub to someone who can't handle dissenting opinions. If you had created the sub, which you are more than welcome to make one and you have the ability to do that. It wouldn't be any of my business but you are asking me to make an admin choice to hand a previously created sub owned by an undeleted user to you because you want it and if I don't do it you are going to make a huge deal about it and threaten me in PMs about making it a public debate.
You told me 4 days ago that my banlist was a problem for you and basically said you wouldn't hand it over to me. This submission wasn't up 4 days ago. None of this was public.
That type of behavior shows me you are not someone I want to hand Ownership status of anything to.
I'm a pretty reasonable guy but I do not respond well to threats.
Threats? I'm not threatening anything. I'm being gaslighted by you, and you're trying to paint me in a negative light. Your rejection of my request sent a message that I wrote in DMs to clarify. You refused to get back to me - why wouldn't I think you were basically on the verge of removing me? You'll forgive me for quoting what was in DM:
I've been defending your status as mod. I think you can adapt to poal's culture. We don't do powermodding here. Its just not going to be a thing.
I appreciate that. I do. But it reads as an inevitability of removal. "Powermodding" apparently defined as ??? I don't even know anymore. Too many bans? For the most hated sub on your platform? For the most hated USERS on your platform? Absurd.
... I just read your invitation to make my own sub so I'll stop there.
You'll leave my sub alone and I can ban all the jackwagons and have a banlog like this one and you won't intervene? I mean, AS LONG AS I DO NOT BAN ANYONE THAT HAS NOT INTERACTED WITH MY SUB, right?
If you're good with that, publicly, I'll move us all to another sub and we'll bury the hatchet here.
Crensch you didn't create the sub. It was created by 1 year ago.
So it wouldn't be taking over the sub.
If all I had to do was migrate them to another sub, I'd do that.
If you're still going to take a sub from me despite the fact that I made it, there's no reason to still be here.
If you're still going to take a sub from me
lol The sub doesn't belong to you and never will (you are just an appointed mod). No matter how much you're gonna brag about it. Especially after exposing your despicable attitude on mumble (last month) when talked to you in a very respectable way and you kept bragging "my sub".
I wasn't bragging.
Your rule about where subs go was not something I was aware of until your snide little ass finally explained it to me. It's not written anywhere in the ToS or UserGuide.
I asked repeatedly on mumble if moving to my own sub would solve this problem and the response SEEMED to be basically, "no".
Now that's the solution according to . So what will you say then, ? That banning users that interact with my sub is not okay?
I would welcome you to do that, so this would no longer be an issue that I need to deal with. You have the ability to make a sub nothing is stopping you.
I asked if this was the thing to do weeks ago on mumble and didn't get an answer.
I'd have done this then, and it wouldn't have been a problem for anyone.
Communicate clearly with me, dude. I'm a simple guy and only really care about moving forward.
So it wouldn't be taking over the sub.
That's exactly what it would be, and you know it. You didn't build this sub, or bring the users here, or help set it up with the [O] a year ago, or have responsibility for the users handed off to you.
Your silly "year-absent ownership goes to admins" isn't written in ToS or user guide, you TOLD me that over voice chat.
I haven't done anything first of all.
I also have in the ToS abusive mods may be removed at anytime(paraphrasing)
I am very sorry you are upset.
I would suggest you just create a sub and we put this unpleasantness behind us.
Edit: If/when you do, don't forget to introduce it in
(post is archived)