I really like the way you broke this down. I think I've read these verses, but so long ago I didnt have the right perspective. I do find this interpretation of forgiveness the most sensible and intuitive version I've heard to date. Pastors of churches always going on about how you should just keep forgiving because if God wants to He will handle it.
People dont seem to remember God uses his people to perform actions on His behalf, but maybe I've got that wrong. But I also don't think God meant for His people to just stand around while He smites all the pedophiles with lightning. We are the lightning!
(Edit to add ping: )
Pastors of churches always going on about how you should just keep forgiving because if God wants to He will handle it.
Christian churches have become extremely feminized over the past 50 years. Which isn't to throw shade at women. If you delivered fire and brimstone the second time your toddler spilled a glass of milk, none of us would have made it out of childhood. A great deal of forgiveness for accidental mistakes is crucial to childrearing. Extending that same level of female sympathy to adults is a grave mistake, and one well-intentioned churches have fallen into.
And if you doubt that Christian churches have become feminized, look at the audience. It's disproportionately female now because "forgiveness without repentance" only resonates if you're raising toddlers.
(post is archived)