Have you read the books?
Had you. a bunch of it would make far more sense.
I watched about 15 minutes of it myself, and being a fan if the series. I have issues with it.
I have issues with the race washing and shit in it. But there are messages that are in the books that seem one way, for a long time. like men suck, and then shift drastically the other way for a while. over a series of 14 books.
Its not quite cannon to be at the start of the series, but series believable for a set of red sisters to be chasing down a man who can channel.
Later in the books, when the man, shoes that he can handle and handful of these women, only a couple if very powerful, with ease. does the message stay the same?
When he is making them swear oaths of fealty, when a man is gaining an entire population and taking over the world. does that scream men suck?
Read it, before you try to judge the ideas presented. But do judge after you have read it, for then your opinion is valuable when discussing fantasy setting with so much written cannon. Until then, you lack the understanding to bitch.
He's talking about the SJW series which just came out. It drips SJW subversion and diversity, simply from the previews.
Understand books and movies are very different things. This version was made with subversive, destructive societal goals in mind. It really doesn't reflect upon the source material.
Correct. After 10 minutes, you can tell why Amazon chose the source material. They can use it to denigrate white men.
Then they can toss niggers everywhere else and pretend it's high fantasy.
Thank God LOTR was made an epic movie before today's age. I'd hate to see the monstrosity if they'd have created it today.
It's sad because the wheel of time has the potential to make GoT and LOTR look like child's play if done properly.
Understood. But many of the direct issues he pointed out. Are things that are very present in the books.
They all already start out too old. Egwaine does get her hair into a braid on bel tine day... the day the first episode is set.
Aes Sedai - dont go to pl;aces and say who they are... they are largely untrusted and misunderstood by the general population. She arrives in the village with Lan, under the names of Alice and Andra. Just travellers looking for old stories. She discovers Teveran after arrival, not before... soe of that is pretty minor, and can be glossed over for the need to condense a 30 hour read of book one, into a few hours of TV. A bunch of the stuff in those 9 chapters that are before the start, are needed for the story. I dont know how or if they intend to work them in.
I am not saying, they arent laying a bunch of bullshit into it also. Hell Egwaine is a fuckin abo... When the dark people are the seafolk and the tairens. The Aiel are listed as deeply tanned, but from sun. So Rand could be done well as a tall white guy.
Perrin is fucked from the start. He wasnt married at that point. And not to some fuckin abo. He marries something closer to a chink (well as closely as decribed - high slanted almond eyes with high cheek bones) I want to say in book 4 but it could be 3. They introduce to her father / mother for the first time in book 6. His family needs to die... mother father brother and sisters... he needs to rail about his 9 year old brother not a dead wife... I dont know how they would reconcile that... its way outside of the books.
So far. with only a few minutes watched. I was pretty disappointed.
Now i have to go see the rest of the episode to see how much worse it gets.
Considering how many times I have read this series. I should have been so eager for the release of this that i watched it 3 or 4 times already. I watched 15 mins and walked away.
(post is archived)